YES! the dick pics will come but they will be downvoted into oblivion anyway. So many times I have wanted to reply to someone with another meme or a pic of my own and words just don't have the same effect.
I don't find the social features all that appealing myself as I never share anything to FB anyway and I could still post the image or link to it that way. If losing it makes the site better then go for it.
As long as it has its own tab/section or a filter that you can turn on and off then I'm all for it. There are plenty of NSFW stuff that can be funny and the community is being deprived of seeing funny posts without it. If people want to see it then great and if they don't all they have to do is turn the filter off. Simple enough.
replydetachattach picture